Tuesday March 9, 1:05 p.m.
First off, I'm happy that
"The Cove" was made. Second of all, I'm also happy that
"The Cove" got
an Oscar, thereby increasing its profile worldwide. The people of
Taiji, Wakayama Prefecture are certainly feeling the opposite. It never feels too good when you've been depicted as
de facto baby seal killers. I've only seen a few scenes on TV of this film, but I have to admit that my blood ran cold when I saw those dolphins being literally beaten to death and the water running red.
I tend to look at both sides of an issue which has worked for and against me (there I go again). Must be the
Libra in me. It is extremely easy for anyone to side with the producers of this project and environmentalists in general when watching this documentary. So, allow me to play
Devil's Advocate (or
Angel's...if you're a
Taiji resident...then again, most likely you wouldn't be able to read this, would you?).
So, why is everyone raising a mighty hue and cry about
dolphins being bashed into
surimi paste once a year when cows and chickens are being executed for their meat on a daily basis in
Europe, America and just about everywhere else? Simple...dolphins are cute creatures with a modicum of intelligence on perhaps the level of an average sheepdog. Dolphins are the go-to animals on all those sea aquarium pictures, and the marine creatures that everyone would love to take pictures with. Plus, they've got that perpetual smile people just get weak in the knees over. They're beautiful creatures, and most people couldn't ever see them being culled into
sashimi....well, except the folks living around
that cove. On the other hand, cows aren't exactly photogenic, and when most people look at them, they suddenly wonder about the terms: rare, medium or well done. Plus, the bovines and farm fowl probably just have the intelligence of a block of oak. Hard to imagine seeing
Bessie doing
the Moonwalk on its taile while juggling a ball on the end of its nose. So there may be a bit of hypocrisy here...or perhaps even a bit of discrimination? Are we being just a tad
intellig-ist or
cute-ist? Oh, we can't eat
Flipper....it's jumping through a hoop....it's nuzzling little Cathy's cheek...it's just looking oh-so-adorable.
Bessie? Ring that dinner bell....steak on the hoof.
Chicken Little? Get the
Colonel over here!
Still, what tipped me over to the side of the producers behind
"The Cove" is just the way the so-called "fishermen" got their bounty. Yep, cows are given the bolt through the head and chickens are just simply given the axe behind closed factory doors, but to see what was going on so starkly...sorry, but no animal deserves to go through that fate. I just thought, fairly or unfairly, about how
the Jews were treated by
the Nazis. And the other telling difference....cows and chickens are livestock; they've been
bred to be eaten (and yep,
PETA will come up with a counterargument on that very point, but I digress). However, these dolphins are just dolphins straight and free from the sea, which have somehow been corralled into this cove and then slaughtered. It's kinda like watching hunters bringing in a whole herd of deer into one pen and then just firing away. No sport in that at all.
The
Taiji residents have given their rebuttal with one fellow looking rather forlorn and just saying that he was
"absolutely dismayed" at the awarding of
the Oscar to these foreign interlopers. This is a years-long tradition, they say. Well, a
tradition is an activity that occurs at regular intervals to commemmorate a certain phenomenon or day. It isn't automatically conferred a good or evil status. That is up to we humans. And as a human, I declare this tradition to be wrong. However, all the world's environmentalists and politicians will not change this tradition. I think it'll come when Japan's bankbook is affected in terms of lost revenue if people start boycotting products or tourism. Then, I can see
Hatoyama and the boys coming down on this small town.