Thursday January 28, 9:00 a.m.
Another one of those late night-early morning transitions. I'm actually pretty good at it, although the question begs about why I should continue doing it. However, if things don't improve at Speedy's within the next few months, I may not have to worry about such things any longer.
I've just about finished the DVD set of
Series 4 of
"Doctor Who". I've gone through all of the episodes and the commentaries, and now I'm just wrapping up with the
en masse viewing of
"Doctor Who Confidential". This show has definitely come a long way since those years of the
Classic Series. I don't think anyone could've envisioned weekly making-of broadcasts of this program back then. And certainly this season will probably go down as the most dramatic one in the show's 47-year history (yes, I am cognizant of the fact that there was no regular series between 1988 and 2005).
When I first saw
Catherine Tate as
Donna Noble in
"The Runaway Bride", I just thought that she was the absolute worst companion to appear in a
TARDIS. Rude, mouthy, selfish....I'd heard of Tate's comedy show in which she specialized in playing a lot of unlikeable characters. Well, frankly, my opinion of her was
"Not in my TARDIS!"Then, the
Martha year came and gone, and then I no longer got video tapes of the show from The Entrepreneur since my VCR up and died and since he got up and married. I did cheat, though, and saw that last tragic scene of
Donna "dying" in the
TARDIS via
YouTube soon after
"Journey's End" had aired but never saw any of her season...at least until I bought the DVD set during the Holidays. So, I was running almost 2 years behind. I did get a glimpse of how nice Donna became, though.
As soon as I started watching
Series 4 with
"Partners in Crime", I knew
Donna, even before she had her reunion with
The Doctor, had become an improved version within the first few minutes of the episode. And the reunion itself, a 2-minute skit in comedic mime, was probably one of the more humourous scenes I'd seen of the show. Try to imagine any of the other companions...even
Rose...pull this off. Over the episodes, this Donna not only became a better person for her travels but became a truly good...platonic...companion for
the Time Lord. She became a buddy....something very rare that The Doctor needed. Going over all of my knowledge of the various companions since
1963, I could only come up with two other people who could have possibly achieved that status:
Jamie McCrimmon during
the 2nd Doctor's years and
Romana 2 during the 4th's time. And even the latter might be a bit suspect, since there was a hint of flirtation between
the Time Lord and the Time Lady...on and off screen. All of the other companions were, more or less, acting as his acolytes or his lovesick admirers (et tu,
Sarah Jane?)
Donna may not have been
The Doctor's equal in all things
Time Lord-y, at least not until her very last regular episode, but she more than made up for that in the human things. And she was very willing to stand up and tell him he was wrong. And there was never a hint of anything romantic...which was something I was getting a bit antsy about with the previous two companions. So, without the emotion of love fogging things up in
the TARDIS, the Doctor and Donna made a good team with the two of them improving over their brief time....which made things all the more tragic when the even briefer appearance of
the DoctorDonna had to be excised. Obviously, Donna didn't die physically but the soul of the new improved version did, to be returned to her original
Lucy Van Pelt self. There have been a lot of bricks thrown at
Russell T. Davies along with the flowers, but I don't think anyone could've been so brave to write that arc in. There had been three other deaths of companions over the 47 years but character was never a huge priority in
the Classic Series so their physical deaths didn't have nearly as much resonance as Donna's psychic one. It was somewhat painful to see Donna revert to her unpleasant persona, but the very last episode of
David Tennant's reign,
"The End of Time, Part 2", provided a small coda and a bit of hope. Another year passed and although Donna was perhaps not as near to her elevated self in her TARDIS year but she seemed to have become somewhat better as a human being, thanks to a bit of attudinal improvement in her harrdian-like mother and the true love of a man.
Still, I'd like to think that Donna's song is not quite finished yet (to adopt an
Ood-ism). Her memories are suppressed not erased, and so I think there is still a story yet to be related about her currently hidden
Time Lady. In a way, though, I think the arc of
Donna Noble is similar to that of
Icarus...someone who had gone for a goal far too lofty and was destined to crash. The new boss behind
"Doctor Who", Stephen Moffatt, has made some great stories for the show, but he'll have some big shoes to fill when it comes to the new Doctor-companion dynamic between
Matt Smith and Karen Gillan.